Case #9

Directions:
Click here to open your browser's e-mail system. This is where you will record your answers to questions plus any comments you want to pass along to your instructor. After entering your answers, you can check your response by clicking "Faculty Comments".  In the subject line of the e-mail form, enter your name and the name of the case being submitted, i.e., Case #9." When you finish your session with Family Medicine On-line, click the Send button in the e-mail window to forward your answers to your instructor. If you end your session before completing the case, click the Send button to submit your answers, and then exit your browser.

To complete the case during another session, go to the first page of the case and click the link above and then advance to the page where you left off. When finished with this session, click the Send button in the e-mail window. All materials copyrighted 2003 by Penn State University.

If you have completed case I, this is a review. Completion of this case will not be counted toward your assignment.


Chief Complaint

Abigail Miller is a 34 year-old Caucasian woman who presents to your family practice office complaining of headaches.

 

  1. What questions will you ask regarding her symptoms?

History of Present Illness

She describes her current headaches as happening every day in mid-afternoon for the past month. The pain is steady, non-pulsatile, and starts in the occipital region with bilateral radiation to the frontal area. There is no associated aura or photophobia. She is not awoken from sleep with the headaches and she does not wake up in the morning with a headache. Tylenol lessens the discomfort "sometimes." Her physical exam is unremarkable with normal vital signs and neurological exam.

When asked if there were any other complaints Mrs. Miller wishes to discuss, she mentions significant stress at home regarding her 9 year-old son. Her concern centers on continued problems with discipline. "He just won't listen to me anymore -- he's always beating up on his little brother and getting into fights at school. His grades have really dropped and he might even be held back this year. I just don't know what to do."

In reviewing Mrs. Miller's chart you note she has been in to your office 7 times over the past year:

October 14 - CC concern re: discipline of her 9 year-old son
   Discussed parenting techniques

July 30 - CC consistent abdominal pain during menses
   Began evaluation for endometriosis

July3 - CC B/L knee pain
   S/P MVA, trial of NSAIDs

June 21 - CC MVA
   BIL ecchymoses of knees

May 8 - CC difficulty falling asleep
   Discussed job stress, Rx for Ambien

March 12 - CC sore throat
   DX pharyngitis

January 10 - CC headaches, abdominal pain
   DX muscle contraction headaches, mittleschmirtz

You also note that Mrs. Miller is due for her annual physical in one month. As you further discuss her son's behavior problems, you notice the patient checking her watch. Due to time you had to spend with a previous patient, you are running 45 minutes behind schedule. Mrs. Miller says she would like to further discuss ways to handle her child, but insists she must be home in 15 minutes. She appears anxious to leave promptly.

  1. What is your plan for Mrs. Miller at this point?

Test Results

Mrs. Miller returns for her annual physical exam. Reviewing the chart prior to entering the room, you note she is a college graduate and works part-time as a nursery school teacher. She and her husband, an accountant, have two sons, ages nine and six. PMH includes hypothyroidism (she takes Synthroid l25mcg each day) and headaches (she takes Tylenol 650mg two or three times a day).

Labs: TSH from 6 months ago = 0.l5mcg/mL and cholesterol two years ago = 172mg/dL.

 

  1. What should be included in a health maintenance visit for a 34 year-old woman?
  2. What health prevention topics should be addressed as part of the visit?
  3. From what we know of Mrs. Miller so far, what do you suspect is troubling her besides her headaches? What are the clues?
  4. When domestic violence is suspected, how should it be addressed?

Social History

Keeping the above information in mind, you continue the conversation with Mrs. Miller.

You asked: "Is there something you would like to discuss."

Mrs. Miller: "I…well I never really told anyone."

You replied: "Anything we discuss here is confidential. It seems as if you may be concerned about your safety at home."

Further discussion reveals that Mrs. Miller's husband has become increasingly controlling over the past few years. In fact, he often calls home up to ten times per day, making sure Mrs. Miller comes home right after work or appointments and stays at home until he returns from work. Mrs. Miller then discloses that he grabbed her around the neck one time. "But it was only once... and that was a few weeks ago. It was probably my fault, because dinner wasn't ready when he got home, and he becomes kind of hypoglycemic."

The patient also states her husband shoved her a few months ago in the kitchen during a dispute over how she has been handling their son. The following day she went to the ED after work. X-rays of her lower extremities showed no fractures, but significant swelling persisted in her knees for a few weeks.

 

  1. It is often difficult for physicians to formulate a question to screen for domestic violence. What are some ways in which you could ask your patient about domestic violence in their home?
  2. What percentage of women report physical abuse (being at least pushed or shoved) at some point in their life? What percentage of women report similar abuse during the last year?
  3. When victims of domestic violence see their primary care physician, what types of complaints do they usually describe?
  4. What are some of the risk factors that should heighten awareness for domestic violence?
  5. What variations are there in prevalence of domestic violence with regard to ethnic groups, education level, socioeconomic status or geographical location?
  6. Mrs. Miller reassures her physician that she feels safe going back to her home, and that she in fact does not want to leave. Do you strongly encourage her to leave her home at once? If she is not willing to leave, are you able to make her leave?
  7. What questions should you ask your patient to assess the danger level inside the home?
  8. Why do battered women often remain in the home where the abuse occurs?
  9. What steps do you recommend Mrs. Miller take at this point to assure she has the ability and means to leave should the situation at home worsen?
  10. What services will be available at the domestic violence shelter?
You don't hear from Mrs. Miller for 4 months. Then she presents to your office with a request for a pregnancy test, in order to verify a positive home test completed two days ago.

 

  1. What concerns do you have for the patient regarding this pregnancy?
  2. Aside from the primary care office, where do victims of domestic violence go for help?
  3. What behaviors, in addition to actual physical assault, are seen in homes where domestic violence is occurring?
  4. Who are the perpetrators of domestic violence?
  5. Is a history of partner violence a risk factor for suicide attempts by women?

Follow-up

Over the next few months, you see Mrs. Miller in your office for prenatal visits as well as for continued difficulty sleeping and back aches. Mrs. Miller delivers a healthy daughter with no complications. At each visit, you discuss the situation at home and provide information regarding the local shelter. Eighteen months after Mrs. Miller's initial disclosure, she decides she is ready to leave the abusive environment. She and her children go to the local shelter, obtain a PFA against her husband, and begin searching for permanent housing.

Primary care physicians have a unique opportunity to identify and interrupt domestic violence. Through increased awareness among health care providers, patients suffering from abuse in the home are being identified and treated.

Continue to next page



Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center ©2004
This page was last updated on April 24, 2006
Contact Us