Case 1

Vision Change Case Study #1: Acute Monocular Vision Change

I. Initial Presentation

In response to your question "What brings you here today? How can I help you", Mr. Moore, a 68 YO retired engineer with a h/o CAD (MI in 1992 with angioplasty) and diverticulitis who has come to your office, sheepishly explains that he is only here because his wife made him come. He said he had "some trouble seeing" this afternoon.



Question 1: Such a brief, cryptic explanation is common. What would you do now?
Answer to Question 1

In response to your closer questioning, Mr. Moore said that he lost total vision in his left eye. It began about 12:30 after lunch and was like a shade coming down over his eye. It lasted for about 3 minutes and then his vision came back fairly abruptly.

Question 2: What 3 very important things do you need to know in the history that weren't directly mentioned?
Answer to Question 2

He indicates that there was no pain or trauma related to these events and that this has never happened before today.

Question 3: What other 3 questions can yield surprising results/help you in your diagnosis?
Answer to Question 3

He says that he had a sore throat and the "flu" a week and a half ago, lasting almost a week. He really has no idea what the problem could be, but that last month he had also had some significant weakness in his right hand and arm that lasted about 30 minutes, but resolved. He thought it was nothing important and hadn't even told his wife and wasn't sure if it was relevant now.

Question 4: At this point, we have a picture of acute, brief vision loss in 1 eye. What items would be in the differential diagnosis?
Answer to Question 4

It's time now for the Physical Exam. The results are as follows:

HEENT:
Eyes:EOMI, PERRL, no Marcus Gunn pupil, no temporal tenderness or jaw claudication
Ears: NL TM's
Nose: No discharge
Neck: supple, few shotty cervical nodes palpated B/L, harsh bruit in right side of the neck
Throat: no oropharyngeal erythema/exudates

Neuro: Cranial Nerves II-XII grossly intact
Heart: RRR, no murmurs or rubs appreciated
Lungs: CTAB
Abdomen: Soft/Non-Tender/No masses

You turn on the light to signal your staff that you'd like someone to come bring the patient into the procedure room with the slit-lamp to more fully examine the patient's retina. While you're waiting and chatting with the couple, Mr. Moore exclaims that "it's happening again". The nurse comes in to bring Mr. Moore to the procedure room and place him in it while you answer a quick call. A few minutes later, you see the following via the slit lamp:



RetinalArterialOcclu.jpg (11880 bytes)


Based on your history and physical, you're now pretty sure it either a Central or Branch Retinal Artery Occlusion. The history of an acute, monocular, painless, transient vision loss is consistent with this diagnosis. Further, you heard a neck bruit which might well indicate a plaque causing carotid stenosis and occasionally showering emboli to the eyes and/or brain (which could account for transient possible TIA/right arm palsy) -- although you heard the bruit on the right side and the vision problem is on the left.

Conversely, Giant-Cell Arteritis is unlikely since there was no temporal tenderness or jaw claudication. Also, there is no trauma and the retinal exam is not consistent with Retinal Detachment - which can reveal an elevated retina and/or retinal folds (see Table 1). Finally, Vitreous Hemorrhage is less likely since the pt gave no history of trauma or floaters and has no predisposing condition for neovascularization such as diabetes.


Question 5: At this point, what should you do?

Answer to Question 5


In this rare case, a textbook maneuver actually works and, much to the Moores' relief (and yours), his vision is restored- for now.

If more time had elapsed without intervention, you might have seen the following:



cent_art_occlu.jpg (7113 bytes)



After vascular stasis, you can see "boxcarring" (rows of corpuscles separated). Later still, the retinal inner layer becomes opalescent, especially around the fovea, resulting in a "cherry-red-spot"

But, remember, this problem still needs to be addressed immediately. You call your buddy from medical school who is now an opthalmologist to see if he can fit Mr. Moore into his schedule today. Your buddy sees him, concurs with your assessment and immediately refers him to another friend who is now a vascular surgeon. She orders a carotid doppler before seeing the patient.

Question 6: What results would be consistent with your physical exam (right neck bruit), but a vision loss on the left?
Answer to Question 6

The surgeon sits down with the Moores to explain the pro's and con's of surgery. She starts with explaining the anatomy and pathology. Then she explains that a recent study showed a yearly 6% chance of a stroke in pts who had been symptomatic (TIAs, amaurosis fugax, or mild strokes) (1) and clearly there is a risk of further vision loss.
(1): Mansour MA, et al, J Vasc Surg, 1995 Feb; 21(2): 346-56.

Question 7: Where is the most common area for a carotid plaque?
Answer to Question 7


Question 8: Of course, there is a risk in the surgery, too. What complication has the highest risk? What is the mortality of a carotid endarterectomy?
Answer to Question 8


If the risk of the surgery is less than the risk of stroke, many pts will opt for the surgery. But physicians must also remember that even if the risk/benefit ratio seems to point in one direction, pts may still take the other option because of value judgements. Further, life expectancy plays a part in this decision for some pts.

Mr. Moore's previous CAD history also plays a part in the risk/benefit analysis. He undergoes pre-op testing which reveals adequate cardiac function and no other contraindicating conditions. He agrees to the surgery and, as a pre-op test, the surgeon orders an arteriogram. It looks like this:




arteriogram.jpg (9801 bytes)

They begin the surgery, first disecting everything out:
operation.jpg (13840 bytes)



Meticulous dissection is essential to avoid dislodging emboli from the carotid plaque as well as protecting cranial nerves such as the hypoglossal and vagus. Cerebral blood flow is also a concern during the operation. Some surgeons shunt blood from the common carotid to the distal internal carotid while others use operative monitoring via EEG - and some do both. In Mr. Moore's case the surgeon chooses to monitor via EEG, deeming shunting unnecessary. The plaque they removed was pretty impressive:


plaque.jpg (11519 bytes)

Then they use the graft that was dissected out (often from the saphenous vein) to enlarge the vessel around that area.
graft.jpg (10546 bytes)
The surgery goes well and there are no complications. Mr. Moore goes home and is prescribed aspirin daily.

phillies1.jpg (4966 bytes) He recouperates by the time it's opening day for the Phillies' and enjoys watching them beat the Dodgers 4-2. phillies2.jpg (2937 bytes)




End of Case 1

Start Case 2


 Return to Vision Problem/Change Tutorial main page



Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center ©2004
This page was last updated on November 13, 2003
Contact Us